Ministry can be a lonely place and those with whom you can confide are few.
I’ve been a pastor for more than ten years now, and while it is certainly greatly rewarding at times, it’s also the most difficult job I’ve ever done. I worked in secular jobs for twenty six years before becoming a pastor, so I’m not speaking without experience in other areas. I’ve written, in general, about how hard it can be to pastor before but I’d like to focus on one specific area of difficulty for those in ministry: isolation.
It’s often very lonely as a pastor. There are seemingly always people around you, but there are very few in whom you can confide. It seems too, that the longer you are in the ministry, the shorter the list of confidants gets.
Here is a part of the predicament. Much of what a pastor deals with in his congregation is completely confidential. People share their secrets with you because they know you will keep their secrets safe. Those secrets range from past sins, to current struggles with integrity or morality, from financial difficulties to marital problems, and so on. They include things that would destroy unity, break confidence and stir strife. So, much of what is said in confidence to the pastor must remain that way forever. You are often carrying the weight of the congregation around with you, attempting with all that is in you to; help bear a brother’s or sister’s burden, restore those overtaken in a sin, arbitrate disagreements and give wise counsel.
I’ve been a pastor for more than ten years now, and while it is certainly greatly rewarding at times, it’s also the most difficult job I’ve ever done. I worked in secular jobs for twenty six years before becoming a pastor, so I’m not speaking without experience in other areas. I’ve written, in general, about how hard it can be to pastor before but I’d like to focus on one specific area of difficulty for those in ministry: isolation.
It’s often very lonely as a pastor. There are seemingly always people around you, but there are very few in whom you can confide. It seems too, that the longer you are in the ministry, the shorter the list of confidants gets.
Here is a part of the predicament. Much of what a pastor deals with in his congregation is completely confidential. People share their secrets with you because they know you will keep their secrets safe. Those secrets range from past sins, to current struggles with integrity or morality, from financial difficulties to marital problems, and so on. They include things that would destroy unity, break confidence and stir strife. So, much of what is said in confidence to the pastor must remain that way forever. You are often carrying the weight of the congregation around with you, attempting with all that is in you to; help bear a brother’s or sister’s burden, restore those overtaken in a sin, arbitrate disagreements and give wise counsel.
On top of that weight, add in the pressure of those in the congregation who don’t care for the direction they feel you are taking the church. In that group include those who constantly express their desire for a different style of worship, a shorter service, a longer service, the inclusion of someone in a ministry position, the exclusion of someone from a ministry position, those who feel that your message left out a main point, those who think you should preach a more positive message, or those who think your message was just not hard enough on sin, those who think you are being a little too judgmental of sin. The list just begins there. I’ve barely scratched the surface, but you get the picture. What all of those opinions actually accomplish, is to drive you further and further from closeness with anyone in the congregation.
If you want to get a fuller picture, add this is in the mix as well. The most natural confidant for a married pastor, is his wife. Most people with careers talk about their job in stressful times as a source relief. Women in particular, seem to feel that this is extremely important for the relationship of the couple. Yet in ministry there is much that a pastor cannot share with his spouse, for confidence’s sake. Those things that can be shared still often have the potential to cause such a weight on the spouse, such heaviness, or concern, that sometimes that source of relief becomes nonexistent too. Sharing those things can impact a marriage by bringing in too much stress, not sharing them can affect the marriage because of secrecy. If a pastor shares with his wife, the disappointments, disillusion, or disenchantment he feels because of the congregation, it most certainly will affect her perception of the people as well. So he is often quiet, or out of necessity he shares his feelings, and the feeling of isolation spreads to his spouse as well.
The most likely confidant, and perhaps one of the best choices, is another pastor who knows exactly what he’s feeling, a peer who also needs a sounding board. As simple as that solution for pastoral isolation sounds, it’s really just not that easy. Perhaps it’s pride, perhaps it’s a tactic of our enemy, or perhaps it’s something else but it’s very difficult to open up to another pastor and share your difficulties. Firstly, you know he has enough problems of his own and doesn’t need yours. Secondly, it makes us feel vulnerable or it might appear as though we are failing. We might look like we are weak in leadership. Our statements might vilify the people in the ministry that we love so much. (Yes, it's true, we love them and don't want people to think of them badly.) We may even worry that the other pastor's ministry may not feel like this to him, and that he may not understand.
The most likely confidant, and perhaps one of the best choices, is another pastor who knows exactly what he’s feeling, a peer who also needs a sounding board. As simple as that solution for pastoral isolation sounds, it’s really just not that easy. Perhaps it’s pride, perhaps it’s a tactic of our enemy, or perhaps it’s something else but it’s very difficult to open up to another pastor and share your difficulties. Firstly, you know he has enough problems of his own and doesn’t need yours. Secondly, it makes us feel vulnerable or it might appear as though we are failing. We might look like we are weak in leadership. Our statements might vilify the people in the ministry that we love so much. (Yes, it's true, we love them and don't want people to think of them badly.) We may even worry that the other pastor's ministry may not feel like this to him, and that he may not understand.
The truth is these feelings are common, or should I say universal. Ministry, especially to pastor a church, is a lonely assignment. Everything we do is very personal, and carries great personal weight in our psyche, yet our lives are very public. It has been likened to ‘life in a fishbowl’. Everything we do is scrutinized. Pastor, that will destroy you, your family, and your peace, unless you learn how to deal with it.
Let me advise you to find that confidant. Share with your wife, what you feel wont damage her. She needs to know you’re dealing well with things. Find a pastor friend you can trust and who is on a similar trajectory and open up, become vulnerable, and let him do the same thing. If you need to find a counselor who will listen and give you input, do it. But the best source of relief for the pressure and the isolation that we can feel as pastors, is time with God. It’s indispensible and there is no substitute.
Jesus felt this exact feeling of isolation in the garden of Gethsemane. His disciples were there, but even with His great distress they kept falling asleep. I can surely imagine how disappointing that must have felt to Him. Jesus desperately needed support, but found none in his closest friends. Still He knew that in our greatest times of isolation, our Heavenly Father is near. He poured His hear out to the Father, and found the strength to go on to Calvary.
Let me advise you to find that confidant. Share with your wife, what you feel wont damage her. She needs to know you’re dealing well with things. Find a pastor friend you can trust and who is on a similar trajectory and open up, become vulnerable, and let him do the same thing. If you need to find a counselor who will listen and give you input, do it. But the best source of relief for the pressure and the isolation that we can feel as pastors, is time with God. It’s indispensible and there is no substitute.
Jesus felt this exact feeling of isolation in the garden of Gethsemane. His disciples were there, but even with His great distress they kept falling asleep. I can surely imagine how disappointing that must have felt to Him. Jesus desperately needed support, but found none in his closest friends. Still He knew that in our greatest times of isolation, our Heavenly Father is near. He poured His hear out to the Father, and found the strength to go on to Calvary.
You MUST do the same. You need a confidant. It’s great when we find a peer to come along side us, but they often seem difficult to find. However, the Father isn’t difficult to find. He’s as close to you as your next breath. Take the heaviness, the disappointments, the difficulties to Him. Meet with Him as often as is needed. Stay with Him as long as your case requires. He’s a good listener. He has good advice. There is no charge. You don’t have to be intimidated when sharing the hardest things... And, He has time for you.